Versioning Settings and Picture Libraries Issues

Can you imagine a news website without any sort of control for the pictures being uploaded to the front page?
Content types (CT) are a big part of any well-planned content management system. In our enterprise we have a dedicated content team who is in control of the CTs for the CMS. They are extremely good at what they do and they really have a good grasp about the business, its processes, documents and metadata. Unfortunately, to deal with legacy systems is the issue and our legacy issue is to unify all the websites and its lists with its correct content types.
Early this week I had to find a way to setup and modify the versioning settings for the lists of our sites. As we can see, this can easily be done via Site Settings option. The issue here is that we have hundreds of sites, not to mention all the Team Sites, across all the enterprise. And possibly thousands of libraries. Meaning: It is impracticable to do this via UI. So, programmatically was the choice.
And honestly, this choice did not look so hard… at first at least.
The SPList object model exposes to us all the properties necessary do control these options enumerated in the page (as we will see in our code later) but make no mistake, the solution is not as trivial as one might think. The biggest problem is here: Enable Content approval.
Let’s do a short parenthesis here and reflect about this matter, from the business point of view.
And that’s a vital piece of functionality. Imagine a news website, like or, possibly with hundreds of employees/contractors  working on the website content. They write news stories, upload pictures etc. As an editor, would you give them any level of access they want?  Of course not. In the ideal model, we must have a group of people responsible to approve the content being displayed to the public (i.e. using the Content Approver role). The last thing an editor wants to see is some crazy text flaming around everyone and displaying unacceptable behaviour (i.e. a text with racist remarks), or a picture that does not reflect the news report, or even worse, a picture that can potentially harm the viewers for being shown in the public.
To make short a long story: A content-based enterprise needs someone to be responsible for content approval.
Now, coming back to our technical venue.
Of course we want to enable content approval. So we go ahead and call:
SPList.EnableModeration = true
And out of the blue during some point of the execution an exception is thrown every time this line is called. That was a surprise for me.
So I went on to MSDN to read about the property and the object and…no clues or answer to be found. I went to see what happened with the other libraries using the same code. In the vast majority of the libraries where I ran that code, they let me update this property, but a few did not. so, what went wrong?
Then after some research and no clear answer, I decided to debug the SharePoint DLL via code reflection. I went to see on MSDN which of the SharePoint DLLs contains the SPList object and as indicated it is the Microsoft.SharePoint.DLL.
I’ve got the DLL and then compared the signature of my reflected copy against the copy installed in the GAC. Just to make sure we all were talking about the same “story”.
Note the member signature. There is nothing unusual here. It is a get / set, but let’s take a closed look at the SET method:
Interesting. “if the base template is a picture library then ERROR”.
Regardless of any test or comment. If we are dealing with a picture library, it seems to me that you can not enable content approval for it in SharePoint and immediately an exception is thrown.
IMO, I find this quite odd because in other instances, similar to this case, it is common place to expose another member to validate this test. For example, I would look for something like along the lines SPList.CanEnableContentApproval.
Anyway, moving on, problem found. I am not sure why content approval is not available for picture libraries. Indeed, if you go to the versioning settings for a picture library you won’t even see these options listed.
The solution : As of today, for me the way out of this is to use document libraries to handle the approval process for images. (if you have any other strategies for this matter, please let me know)
Now let’s take a look at the code to handle the full versioning control. Enjoy.
    1         /// <summary>
    2         /// Applies the versioning settings to the list.
    3         /// </summary>
    4         /// <param name="selectedList">The selected list.</param>
    5         public void ApplyVersioningSettings(Microsoft.SharePoint.SPList selectedList)
    6         {
    7             // enable content approval for this list
    8             // moderation is not supported for picture library types
    9             if (selectedList.BaseTemplate != SPListTemplateType.PictureLibrary)
   10                 selectedList.EnableModeration = true;
   12             // enable versioning for this list
   13             selectedList.EnableVersioning = true;
   15             // set security to only users who can approve and the actual content author
   16             selectedList.DraftVersionVisibility = DraftVisibilityType.Approver;
   18             //enable minor versions for this list
   19             selectedList.EnableMinorVersions = true;
   21             //set YES to forced checkin/checkout required
   22             selectedList.ForceCheckout = true;
   23         }
See you later